BAAJA Threatens Tribal Consultation, Sacred Sites, and Treaty Rights
Tribal policy is at the heart of the fight over BAAJA, a federal permitting bill that could change how Tribal Nations protect sacred sites, treaty resources, water, and historic places. Supporters say it will speed energy and infrastructure projects, while Tribal governments and Native organizations warn it could weaken consultation and sovereignty protections.
Earlier this week, the U.S. Senate moved the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 toward passage. It adopted the substitute amendment carrying BAAJA by 69-27, and then voted 65-31 to end debate on the bill. The Senate returned to the bill November 19, with final action still ahead. The Senate’s official vote record
The bill has attracted bipartisan support for legitimate reasons. Large infrastructure and energy projects can take years to navigate overlapping reviews, permitting requirements, litigation, and federal agency delays. BAAJA’s sponsors want to shorten the process. They plan to expand transmission capacity and bring more power to the grid. Developers seek greater certainty. They need a clearer way to assign costs to large electricity users, including data centers.
Those goals are worth pursuing. Tribal Nations have said as much. The National Congress of American Indians (NCAI) backs responsible infrastructure development and permitting reform. Tlingit & Haida explicitly support responsible development and efforts to improve government efficiency. The debate is over what Congress is willing to weaken to achieve that speed. NCAI’s analysis of the amended legislation; Tlingit & Haida’s statement on BAAJA
For more than 70 Tribal Nations, along with major national and regional Native organizations, BAAJA still goes too far. Their objections reach beyond one technical provision of federal preservation law. The bill would narrow when projects receive historic-preservation review. It would change how federal agencies consult with Tribal governments and tighten participation deadlines. It would narrow judicial remedies after agency violations. Additionally, it would modify laws protecting waters, treaty resources, sacred places, and ancestral lands.
Congress is trying to solve a real permitting problem. It should not do so by reducing Tribal Nations’ ability to protect places and rights the federal government has spent generations promising to respect.
The Section 106 fight is about more than preservation paperwork
Much of the Tribal opposition focuses on Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, a federal review process that rarely attracts much public attention until someone proposes changing it.
Section 106 requires agencies to assess effects on historic properties. It also requires consultation with Tribal Nations when significant places may be affected. It does not give a Tribe veto power over a project. The process requires agencies to identify historic properties, assess potential harm, and receive information from THPOs and other consulting parties. Then they consider whether the harm can be avoided or reduced.
The Congressional Research Service describes consultation as the “backbone” of the current Section 106 process. Under existing regulations, consultation can occur throughout the review. Agencies determine the project area and identify historic properties. They assess adverse effects and seek ways to resolve them. BAAJA would make substantial statutory changes to that structure, including narrowing the projects subject to review, defining which effects may qualify as adverse, imposing new deadlines, altering consultation requirements, and limiting judicial review. Congressional Research Service analysis of BAAJA’s NHPA provisions
For Tribal Nations, the process carries particular weight because cultural geography does not follow modern reservation boundaries. Sacred sites, burial grounds, traditional gathering areas, cultural landscapes, and places tied to treaty rights may sit on federal, state, or private land hundreds of miles from current reservation borders. Removal, allotment, land sales, and other federal policies separated Native people from enormous portions of their ancestral homelands. A permitting system that narrows review based on modern jurisdiction or ownership can therefore miss the very places federal consultation was intended to help identify.
National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers (NATHPO) has focused much of its criticism there. Its analysis argues that both the original and amended versions of BAAJA narrow what qualifies as an undertaking and an adverse effect, potentially excluding projects or harms before meaningful Tribal participation occurs. The organization has also objected to provisions allowing agencies greater control over when consultation occurs and what information must be considered. NATHPO’s November analysis of the amended bill
These are not abstract concerns. Prairie Band Potawatomi Nation Chairman Joseph P. Rupnick has pointed to ancient burial mounds as an example of why Section 106 remains central to Tribal preservation efforts, telling Native News Online that such places connect Tribal citizens directly to their history, identity, and ancestors. Weakening consultation, he argued, also weakens the Nation’s ability to protect irreplaceable cultural resources. Native News Online’s reporting on Tribal opposition
BAAJA puts more of the burden on Tribes
Supporters revised BAAJA after Tribal organizations and preservation advocates objected to the original language. Those changes deserve acknowledgment. The amended legislation addresses some concerns surrounding Tribal Historic Preservation Offices and adds resources intended to support preservation work.
The larger framework remains intact, however, and the revised bill still imposes significant procedural burdens on Tribal governments.
The Congressional Research Service (CRS) found that BAAJA would establish new response periods at several points during Section 106 review. In one part of the process, agencies could limit further obligations to consult or consider objections if a Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, State Historic Preservation Officer, or other consulting party failed to respond to a request within 30 days. The agency would then decide whether an objection was sufficiently “substantive,” a term the legislation does not clearly define. CRS also noted uncertainty over how some of the bill’s overlapping consultation deadlines would work in practice. CRS discussion of Section 106 timelines and consultation
Federal reviews should have schedules, and agencies should be expected to meet them. The concern is how BAAJA distributes the consequences when those schedules become difficult to meet. Many THPOs operate with small staffs while reviewing projects across large geographic areas. Their work may require archaeological surveys, oral histories, consultation with elders and cultural experts, review of traditional cultural properties, and careful handling of information that cannot simply be dropped into a public federal record.
A more efficient system would bring Tribal governments into project planning earlier, while still allowing routes, designs, and alternatives to change. BAAJA leans instead toward faster statutory clocks and greater agency discretion. NATHPO has argued that this approach risks leaving Tribal Nations to challenge federal decisions after agencies have already defined the area under review or reached preliminary conclusions about a project’s effects. NATHPO’s detailed BAAJA resource center
The same imbalance appears when disputes reach court. CRS found that BAAJA would impose a 150-day filing period for certain NHPA claims and significantly constrain judicial remedies. Courts could find that an agency violated preservation law yet, in many circumstances, remand the decision without vacating the authorization that allowed the project to proceed. The legislation also limits the availability of preliminary injunctions. CRS legal analysis of the proposed NHPA changes
Project developers have a legitimate interest in avoiding years of uncertainty after obtaining a federal permit. But historic-preservation cases present an obvious problem with remedies that arrive only after construction continues. A federal agency can redo an analysis. It cannot rebuild a burial site, restore a destroyed archaeological feature, or return a sacred landscape to its previous condition once the physical damage is done.
Treaty rights remain, but the tools used to protect them get weaker
Some criticism of BAAJA has described the legislation as an attack on treaty rights. That language can create confusion because the bill does not repeal Indian treaties or extinguish treaty-reserved rights.
Its effect is more practical. Tribal Nations frequently use federal environmental and preservation laws to identify threats to treaty-protected resources before the government authorizes a project. Those laws create opportunities to address effects on fish, wildlife, water, access, sacred places, and other resources while agencies are still deciding what a project will look like and whether it should proceed.
The Shoshone-Bannock Tribes have framed their opposition in precisely those terms. The Fort Hall Business Council argues that BAAJA fails to respect federal trust and treaty responsibilities, including obligations tied to the Fort Bridger Treaty of 1868, and has urged Idaho’s congressional delegation to oppose the legislation. Shoshone-Bannock Tribes’ statement on BAAJA
The concern extends beyond the National Historic Preservation Act. BAAJA also changes the Clean Water Act, including the Section 401 certification process through which states and eligible Tribal Nations review whether federally licensed or permitted projects meet applicable water-quality requirements.
CRS found that the bill would narrow portions of that review and impose new requirements on some certification decisions and conditions. For certain nationwide permits, BAAJA would also expand the acreage of waters that individual projects may affect while remaining eligible for streamlined permitting. CRS analysis of BAAJA’s Clean Water Act provisions
For Tribal Nations whose fisheries, subsistence practices, ceremonies, economies, drinking water, and treaty rights depend on healthy rivers and watersheds, these changes overlap quickly. A transmission corridor or pipeline may involve historic resources, water-quality concerns, treaty species, cultural landscapes, and off-reservation rights at the same time. Federal permitting law divides those questions among statutes and agencies. Tribal communities experience the project as a whole.
Congress also created a consultation problem while rewriting consultation
The process used to develop BAAJA has become part of the substantive dispute.
NCAI, NATHPO, and numerous Tribal governments say the bill was developed without meaningful government-to-government consultation before lawmakers proposed major changes to the legal framework governing Tribal participation. NATHPO Executive Director Ira L. Matt, who previously served as a THPO, has argued that Congress should remove the historic-preservation title and develop replacement language through a process that includes Tribal Nations from the beginning. NATHPO’s November 17 statement
NCAI reported November 16 that more than 70 Tribal Nations were represented among more than 215 entities that had submitted letters, resolutions, statements, or other materials objecting to BAAJA or its proposed Section 106 changes. The positions and requested fixes differ, but the breadth of opposition is substantial. NCAI’s accounting of Tribal opposition
Indian Country is not unanimous, nor should anyone expect it to be. Tribal Nations are separate sovereign governments with different lands, economies, energy interests, cultural resources, treaty histories, and relationships with federal agencies. Some see significant opportunity in faster energy and infrastructure development. Others face projects that put culturally significant places or treaty resources directly in the path of that development.
That diversity makes it especially difficult to justify drafting sweeping changes first and consulting later. Support from one Tribal government cannot stand in for another, just as one state’s approval of federal policy cannot settle the views of the other 49.
NATHPO has made this point repeatedly as lawmakers sought changes that might attract additional Tribal support. Each Nation has the sovereign authority to decide whether BAAJA serves its interests. Congress has the corresponding responsibility to hear those governments directly before rewriting the laws that shape their participation. NATHPO’s November 11 statement
The useful parts of BAAJA can survive without weakening Tribal protections
The case against BAAJA should not become an argument for preserving every feature of the existing permitting system. Federal review can be slow, redundant, and poorly coordinated. Agencies need adequate staff and firm schedules. Energy projects need clearer paths through multiple federal approvals. Transmission remains difficult to build at the scale the country increasingly requires, and developers deserve more certainty after following the rules.
Those problems can be addressed without reducing Tribal Nations’ ability to identify sacred places, raise treaty concerns, protect water, or challenge unlawful federal action before damage becomes permanent.
Earlier Tribal involvement could make permitting more efficient. If a proposed route crosses a burial area, affects treaty-protected fisheries, threatens a cultural landscape, or creates serious water concerns, project developers benefit from discovering that while engineers still have alternatives on a map. Finding out after a permit has been issued is slower and considerably more expensive for everyone involved.
That is also why the Senate should take the breadth of Tribal opposition seriously rather than treating the manager’s amendment as the end of the conversation. On November 17, NCAI and several Native organizations said the revisions still failed to address their fundamental objections and called on Congress to reject BAAJA in its entirety. NCAI and partner organizations’ November 17 statement
Congress should preserve the portions of BAAJA that improve transmission planning, agency coordination, grid capacity, and ratepayer protections. It should remove the provisions that narrow historic-preservation review, reduce meaningful Tribal participation, constrain water-quality authority, or limit effective judicial remedies. Lawmakers can then return to those issues with Tribal governments involved before the language is locked down.
The United States has treaty, trust, and government-to-government responsibilities that do not disappear because a project has a deadline. Permitting reform can move projects faster without making Tribal Nations easier to bypass. BAAJA has not found that balance, and Congress should oppose it in its current form.
So now what?
Time is running out for opponents of BAAJA. The Senate is reviewing the permitting bill today, after cloture, on November 19, narrowing the vote window. Urge both U.S. senators to vote no on BAAJA in its current form. Ask Congress to remove NHPA and Section 106 changes. Re-frame them into a genuine government-to-government process with Tribal Nations. NATHPO is urging senators to remove NHPA provisions and has gathered background materials, Tribal letters, resolutions, and advocacy resources for outreach. These materials can be shared with congressional offices.
Tribal governments, organizations, preservation advocates, and allies should also send written opposition into the congressional record and circulate the NCAI position and supporting Tribal statements.
If the Senate passes the bill, the focus moves to the House. Contact your Congressional representative the same day and reiterate the request. This is the moment to specify what must change and how you expect elected officials to vote.
AI Disclosure: Artificial intelligence tools were used to help locate, organize, and cross-check source materials and citations for this article.